[SEAMSECURITY-66] Separated API/IMPL jars do not allow compilation of the SimpleAuthenticator example - JBoss Issue Tracker

Details

Type: Bug
Status: Open (View Workflow)
Priority: Major
Resolution: Unresolved
Affects Version/s: 3.0.0.Final
Fix Version/s: None
Labels:
- api
- authenticator
- example
- factoring
- impl
- include
- library
- simpleauthenticator

Steps to Reproduce:

Hide

1. Use the SimpleAuthenticator example.
2. Attempt to compile using the separated api/impl jars, with api in the compile scope, and impl in the runtime scope.

Show
1. Use the SimpleAuthenticator example. 2. Attempt to compile using the separated api/impl jars, with api in the compile scope, and impl in the runtime scope.
Affects:

Compatibility/Configuration
Workaround:

Workaround Exists
Workaround Description:

Hide

Use the combined jars, or put the impl jar into the compile scope.

Show
Use the combined jars, or put the impl jar into the compile scope.
Estimated Difficulty:
Low

Description

The SimpleAuthenticator example is not compilable with the separated API/IMPL jars, but instead must use either the combined jars, or the impl jar must be in the compile scope.

This seems like an incorrect factoring of impl vs api classes if the impl classes are required to compile a simple example of a custom authenticator. In particular, the PasswordCredential, BaseAuthenticator and SimpleUser classes are not available if only the API jar is used as a compile time dependency.

Gliffy Diagrams

Issue Links

is duplicated by

SEAMSECURITY-131 Compile time error when following authentication example with seam security dependencies resolved from seam bom

Open

Activity

Hide

Permalink

Hendy Irawan added a comment - 29/Mar/12 8:18 PM

I also get this problem:

[INFO] Compiling 22 source files to /home/ceefour/git/aksimata-web/target/classes

[INFO] -------------------------------------------------------------

[ERROR] COMPILATION ERROR :

[INFO] -------------------------------------------------------------

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[10,30] cannot find symbol

symbol  : class BaseAuthenticator

location: package org.jboss.seam.security

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[12,34] package org.picketlink.idm.impl.api does not exist

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[13,40] package org.picketlink.idm.impl.api.model does not exist

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[23,39] cannot find symbol

symbol: class BaseAuthenticator

public class LdapAuthenticator extends BaseAuthenticator {

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[35,22] cannot find symbol

symbol  : class PasswordCredential

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[46,4] cannot find symbol

symbol  : class SimpleUser

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[46,26] cannot find symbol

symbol  : class SimpleUser

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[48,14] cannot find symbol

symbol  : variable AuthenticationStatus

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[51,14] cannot find symbol

symbol  : variable AuthenticationStatus

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[52,4] cannot find symbol

symbol  : method setUser(<nulltype>)

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[56,13] cannot find symbol

symbol  : variable AuthenticationStatus

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[57,3] cannot find symbol

symbol  : method setUser(<nulltype>)

location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator

[ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[30,1] method does not override or implement a method from a supertype

Workaround:

<properties>

	<seam.version>3.1.0.Final</seam.version>

</properties>

  <dependencyManagement>

    <dependencies>

	<dependency>

		<groupId>org.jboss.seam</groupId>

		<artifactId>seam-bom</artifactId>

		<version>${seam.version}</version>

		<type>pom</type>

		<scope>import</scope>

	</dependency>

	<dependency>

		<groupId>org.jboss.seam.security</groupId>

		<artifactId>seam-security</artifactId>

		<version>${seam.version}</version>

		<scope>compile</scope>

	</dependency>

	<dependency>

		<groupId>org.picketlink.idm</groupId>

		<artifactId>picketlink-idm-core</artifactId>

		<version>1.5.0.Alpha02</version>

		<scope>compile</scope>

	</dependency>

    </dependencies>

  </dependencyManagement>

Please also update the "Affected Version", still happens on 3.1.0.Final.

Show

Hendy Irawan added a comment - 29/Mar/12 8:18 PM I also get this problem: [INFO] Compiling 22 source files to /home/ceefour/git/aksimata-web/target/classes [INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------- [ERROR] COMPILATION ERROR : [INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------- [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[10,30] cannot find symbol symbol : class BaseAuthenticator location: package org.jboss.seam.security [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[12,34] package org.picketlink.idm.impl.api does not exist [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[13,40] package org.picketlink.idm.impl.api.model does not exist [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[23,39] cannot find symbol symbol: class BaseAuthenticator public class LdapAuthenticator extends BaseAuthenticator { [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[35,22] cannot find symbol symbol : class PasswordCredential location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[46,4] cannot find symbol symbol : class SimpleUser location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[46,26] cannot find symbol symbol : class SimpleUser location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[48,14] cannot find symbol symbol : variable AuthenticationStatus location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[51,14] cannot find symbol symbol : variable AuthenticationStatus location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[52,4] cannot find symbol symbol : method setUser(<nulltype>) location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[56,13] cannot find symbol symbol : variable AuthenticationStatus location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[57,3] cannot find symbol symbol : method setUser(<nulltype>) location: class org.soluvas.ldap.LdapAuthenticator [ERROR] LdapAuthenticator.java:[30,1] method does not override or implement a method from a supertype Workaround: <properties> <seam.version>3.1.0.Final</seam.version> </properties> <dependencyManagement> <dependencies> <dependency> <groupId>org.jboss.seam</groupId> <artifactId>seam-bom</artifactId> <version>${seam.version}</version> <type>pom</type> <scope>import</scope> </dependency> <dependency> <groupId>org.jboss.seam.security</groupId> <artifactId>seam-security</artifactId> <version>${seam.version}</version> <scope>compile</scope> </dependency> <dependency> <groupId>org.picketlink.idm</groupId> <artifactId>picketlink-idm-core</artifactId> <version>1.5.0.Alpha02</version> <scope>compile</scope> </dependency> </dependencies> </dependencyManagement> Please also update the "Affected Version", still happens on 3.1.0.Final.

Separated API/IMPL jars do not allow compilation of the SimpleAuthenticator example

Details

Description

Gliffy Diagrams

Issue Links

Activity

People

Dates

Development

Agile